In the aftermath of Gregg Berhalter's firing, it became clear that the USMNT was looking for something different for their next appointment.
Matt Crocker, the technical director for the United States Soccer Federation (USSF), identified the need for a "serial winner." Tyler Adams, Berhalter's captain at the 2022 World Cup, called for a "ruthless" coach to take the team forward to the 2026 World Cup being played largely on home soil -- the defining tournament for this generation of American soccer players.
In Mauricio Pochettino, the USSF is confident it has found the man who embodies those qualities.
The Argentinian former Tottenham Hotspur, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea head coach has the job of turning a team that suffered an embarrassing group-stage exit as Copa America hosts this summer into one capable of going deep enough in 2026 to take soccer to another level in the United States.
Here, The Athletic has analyzed the fit of the USMNT's most prominent stars under their new boss.
Helping develop Harry Kane at Tottenham. Fitting Neymar, Lionel Messi and Kylian Mbappe into one PSG team. Facilitating the emergence of Cole Palmer at Chelsea. Pochettino loves to build the attacking parts of his sides around headline-grabbing forwards. With the USMNT, Pulisic is the most likely candidate.
The 25-year-old has been involved with the senior national team since he was 17 and has become its star attacker. His tears became the symbol of the USMNT's failure to qualify for the 2018 World Cup finals, and his importance to American success in this sport continues to grow.
Pochettino is expected to hand Pulisic the keys to his attack, providing the AC Milan forward with a level of responsibility he relishes. After a defining 2023-24 season at San Siro, Pulisic is in the form of his professional career. Under Pochettino, the onus is going to be on him to carry that form into the international sphere.
Reyna has established himself in the USMNT starting line-up over the past 12 months, but Pochettino's experience of developing No 10s suggests he could now reach another level. Across Pochettino's five years in charge of Tottenham, he helped Christian Eriksen develop from a young talent with elite potential into one of the best midfield creators in the world. Could Reyna follow a similar path?
Reyna has experienced a difficult couple of years since the World Cup in Qatar, failing to establish himself as a key player at Borussia Dortmund in the German Bundesliga. He went on loan to Nottingham Forest in the Premier League for the second half of last season but could not establish himself as they battled to avoid relegation.
The 21-year-old has the talent to become a star under Pochettino, but before the new head coach entrusts him with an important role Reyna, who played only nine minutes in Dortmund's first two games of the season, must find consistent football at the club level.
Workhorse midfielders have been central to Pochettino's teams.
Last summer, Chelsea signed Moises Caicedo for £115million ($146m) from fellow Premier League side Brighton & Hove Albion to add dynamism to his midfield engine room, alongside Enzo Fernandez. At Southampton, his first gig in English football a decade ago, former Northern Ireland international Steven Davis provided the running alongside Morgan Schneiderlin and Victor Wanyama, with the latter then being signed by Spurs after he became manager there. For the U.S., McKennie and Musah seem set to battle for that role under Pochettino.
With a World Cup and Copa America cycle now behind them, Musah and McKennie are seasoned operators for the national team, and it will be up to the new manager to decide which of them best suits his preferred 4-2-3-1 formation. McKennie, 26, is more experienced, started all three group games at the Copa America, and will probably be the favorite to assume the right-sided central midfield role initially.
However, Musah is younger at 21 and has considerable potential, particularly as a passer and ball-carrier. Pochettino, who has never been afraid to give young players time and opportunities to impress, is the perfect boss for him to take the next step and own that spot in midfield.
The Athletic has every angle covered on Mauricio Pochettino's appointment as USMNT head coach:
When fit, Adams is one of the first names on the USMNT team sheet.
He was at his best at the 2022 World Cup, with his finest performance at that tournament -- and arguably his international career -- coming in the goalless group-stage draw against England. Facing Declan Rice, Jude Bellingham and Mason Mount, Adams was crucial in the USMNT winning the midfield battle and controlling large portions of the game, earning him the player of the match award.
Since then though, Adams' career has plateaued. After suffering a season-ending hamstring injury with Leeds United in March 2023, he has endured several setbacks, causing him to miss most of last season. He made his long-awaited return to competitive USMNT action at Copa America, playing in all three matches before aggravating a back injury that caused him to miss the final part of new club Bournemouth's league campaign. He is sidelined again for the opening months of the new season following back surgery.
The 25-year-old is far from finished at club and international level, you'd imagine. He has proven his quality in the Premier League and for his nation, and Pochettino will be keen to see him back to his best, with the defensive midfield spot in his system tailor-made for Adams' qualities.
That said, without the cushion of his strong performances under Berhalter guaranteeing his selection, Adams must prove he can still reach the physical level required from a Pochettino midfielder.
The present and future at the heart of the USMNT defense.
Alongside Denmark international Joachim Andersen, Richards excelled under Oliver Glasner for Crystal Palace in the second half of last season, stepping up to prove his quality after England international Marc Guehi was injured.
Throughout former Argentina international defender Pochettino's time in management, athletic ball-playing center-backs have been important, allowing his sides to build attacking moves from defense and operate a high line. Richards, 24, suits this perfectly, and he appears set to become a nailed-on starter ahead of and during the next World Cup, provided he stays injury-free and continues to play club football consistently at a high level.
Ream was among Berhalter's most reliable servants, but it might be time for the United States to evolve beyond him.
His selection was backed by his consistent performances in an American shirt and for Fulham in the Premier League and Championship. However, Ream will be 37 next month and has now left the Premier League and is playing in MLS for Charlotte. Although Pochettino is not against relying on older center-backs -- Thiago Silva remained an essential part of his Chelsea backline last season despite turning 39 last September.
There is also the question mark of what comes after Ream for the States on the road to World Cup 2026, with Cameron Carter-Vickers largely unproven at the international level and Miles Robinson yet to test himself outside MLS. Without any apparent alternatives, Pochettino's best solution might be sticking with Ream in the short term.
However, any physical decline could limit Pochettino's desire to implement his attacking style. As mentioned with Richards, the Argentinian likes to play high up the pitch with defenders who can cover the space behind him, which could expose Ream.
Balogun could be the player who benefits most from Pochettino's arrival.
More than Palmer, Eriksen, Son or Dele Alli, the player Pochettino developed most in his Premier League years was Kane.
When Pochettino joined Spurs in 2014, the current England captain was a 21-year-old on the fringe of the first team. He had scored four goals in 19 games across competitions the previous season following several indifferent loan spells to lower-league clubs. Within five years, he had become one of the best strikers in the world, scoring 169 goals in 242 appearances under Pochettino.
It's been a while since the USMNT had a reliable goalscorer, and Balogun's performances at Copa America indicated he could be the player to make the No 9 shirt his own.
It's difficult for an international coach to have a game-changing impact on an individual, considering the limited time they get with the players, but it might only take a few minor adjustments to take Balogun from a good striker to a world-class one.
At the other end of the pitch, Turner's place in the team has never been less secure since winning the No. 1 shirt under Berhalter.
Having looked set to be Nottingham Forest's third-choice goalkeeper this season, he now seems certain to be Crystal Palace's second-choice after securing a season-long loan to the London club on the final day of the summer transfer window.
The move is unlikely to help him in his search for regular Premier League football but his case to continue as Pochettino's No 1 is supported by the lack of competition. Ethan Horvath's early-season form for Cardiff City in the second-tier Championship has been patchy. Gaga Slonina, the nation's brightest young talent in his position, is playing at Barnsley in England's third tier on loan from top-flight Chelsea, and the rest of the starting options available to Pochettino are in MLS.
If Turner can break into Palace's team and find his best form, the shirt appears his for the foreseeable future... if not, he opens the door for challengers.
Robinson and Dest have the ideal playing profiles for Pochettino's system, in which emphasis is placed on full-backs who provide width and further cover in midfield.
At Spurs, he used Kyle Walker and Danny Rose in these roles, playing them high and wide to help stretch the opposition's defense and allow interior attackers to operate in the vacated spaces.
Towards the end of last season with Chelsea, he used right-back Malo Gusto similarly but allowed Marc Cucurella to 'invert' from the left side, providing another body in midfield to help the team keep possession while also providing another barrier in the middle of the pitch to protect against transitions.
Given Robinson's electric pace and threat from wide positions, he appears a perfect fit. Dest could go to another level under Pochettino with his quality in possession helping to cut through opposing teams and provides the USMNT with defensive cover if their attacks break down.