Crypto ETFs are safer than owning cryptocurrencies outright - but you're still in unknown territory
With the rise of cryptocurrency-linked exchange-traded funds, many investors believe they've found a safer way to dip into the volatile world of bitcoin (BTCUSD), ether (ETHUSD) and other digital assets. While crypto ETFs offer a layer of protection direct crypto investment lacks, they're not without their own set of risks. Here's what you need to know to protect your crypto holdings:
1. Keep it real: Investing in crypto through ETFs is generally safer than holding cryptocurrencies directly. You're not dealing with digital wallets, private keys or the risk of crypto-exchange hacks. Yet this apparent safety net can lull investors into a false sense of security. Remember, the underlying assets are still highly volatile, and this volatility will be reflected in the ETF's value.
During the bitcoin price crash of 2022, for example, when the popular crypto's value plunged more than 60% from its all-time high, ETFs tracking bitcoin's price saw similar declines. While ETFs protect you from some crypto-specific risks, they don't insulate you from market volatility.
2. Understand what you're buying: When you buy a crypto ETF, you're not getting a standard financial product. You're investing in a fund that holds or tracks cryptocurrencies or blockchain-related companies. You need to know how crypto trading operates. For instance, if your ETF is heavily weighted toward bitcoin, a sudden regulatory crackdown on bitcoin mining could significantly impact your investment. Similarly, a major security flaw discovered in Ethereum could tank the value of ETFs with large ether holdings.
Some crypto ETFs include stocks of companies involved in blockchain technology - ranging from crypto exchanges such as Coinbase Global (COIN) and mining companies such as Marathon Digital Holdings (MARA), to Microsoft (MSFT) and other tech giants investing in blockchain. Publicly traded companies come with their own risks and potential rewards.
Unlike traditional ETFs, crypto ETFs face unique challenges when it comes to asset custody. The companies holding the actual cryptocurrencies for the ETF (known as custodians) are a potential point of failure. If a custodian's security is breached, it could lead to significant losses for the ETF and, by extension, your investment.
3. Custody matters: Always research the custodial arrangements of any crypto ETF you're considering. Look for ETFs that use reputable custodians with a track record of strong security measures, including cold storage for assets and comprehensive insurance policies.
Here's what to ask about an ETF's custodian:
What security measures are in place? Have they ever experienced a security breach? If so, how was it handled?Are multisignature wallets in use? What portion of assets is held in cold storage versus hot wallets? What insurance policies do they have, and what exactly do these policies cover?
The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is still in development, and this uncertainty extends to crypto ETFs. A sudden regulatory change could force an ETF to quickly sell off assets, potentially at unfavorable prices. In extreme cases, regulatory shifts could even lead to the delisting of an ETF.
Stay informed about the regulatory environment in the countries where your ETF operates. Be prepared for the possibility that rules could change rapidly, affecting your investment.
Consider these scenarios:
A country bans cryptocurrency mining, affecting the profitability of mining companies in your ETF's portfolio.New tax regulations are introduced, impacting the ETF's returns or reporting requirements.Stricter know-your-customer (KYC) and anti-money-laundering (AML) rules are implemented, potentially limiting the ETF's ability to trade certain assets.
4. Liquidity trap: Crypto ETFs can face liquidity issues, especially during times of market stress. If a large number of investors try to sell their ETF shares simultaneously, the fund might struggle to sell its crypto holdings fast enough to meet redemption demands. This could lead to the ETF trading at a significant discount to its net asset value. Before investing, check the liquidity of the ETF and its underlying assets. Larger, more established funds tend to have better liquidity.
Here are some factors that can affect an ETF's liquidity:
Trading volume: Higher daily trading volumes generally indicate better liquidity.Assets under management: Larger funds usually have better liquidity.Spread: A narrow bid-ask spread often indicates good liquidity.Creation/redemption process: Understand how the ETF creates and redeems shares, as this can impact liquidity.
5. New scams: While crypto ETFs protect you from many traditional cryptocurrency scams, they've given rise to a new breed of fraudulent activities. Watch out for:
Fake ETFs: Scammers create fraudulent ETFs that mimic legitimate ones. Always verify an ETF's legitimacy through official channels like the SEC's EDGAR database.
Sophisticated phishing: Instead of trying to steal your crypto wallet keys, scammers might impersonate your broker or the ETF company to gain access to your investment account. These attacks can be highly targeted. For example, a scammer might use information from your social-media profiles to craft a convincing impersonation of your financial adviser, then try to persuade you to transfer funds or share account details.
Deepfake dangers: Some scammers use deepfake technology to impersonate financial advisers or ETF executives. Always verify the identity of anyone asking you to make investment decisions, especially if they're pressuring you to act quickly.
Pump-and-dump schemes: While not exclusive to ETFs, pump-and-dump schemes can target smaller or newer crypto ETFs. Scammers might spread false information to inflate the price of an ETF or its underlying assets, then sell their holdings once the price has risen.
Front-running: This is when someone with advance knowledge of a large pending transaction uses that information for their own profit. In the context of ETFs, an unethical insider might use knowledge of the ETF's rebalancing schedule to trade the underlying assets beforehand.
Tracking error
Crypto ETFs, especially those using futures contracts rather than holding cryptocurrencies directly, can suffer from tracking error. This means the ETF's performance may not perfectly mirror the performance of the underlying assets it's meant to track.
Factors contributing to tracking error include:
Management fees Transaction costsDifferences between spot and futures prices (for futures-based ETFs)Rebalancing frequency
Protecting your portfolio
How can you safeguard your investments? Here are some key steps:
1. Do your homework: Thoroughly research any ETF before investing. Understand its holdings, management team and track record. Look into the fund's prospectus, which will detail its investment strategy, risks and fees. Pay attention to the expense ratio; while crypto ETFs tend to have higher fees than traditional ETFs, excessive fees can eat into your returns.
2. Secure your brokerage account: Use strong, unique passwords and hardware-based two-factor authentication. Be wary of using public wifi for accessing your investment accounts.
3. Stay informed: Keep up with news about the cryptocurrencies your ETF holds and any regulatory developments. Follow reputable financial news sources and consider setting up alerts for news related to your investments.
4. Diversify: Don't concentrate your portfolio. Crypto ETFs should be part of a diversified portfolio, not your main investment strategy. Consider your risk tolerance and investment goals when deciding what portion of your portfolio to allocate to crypto ETFs.
5. Be skeptical: If an investment opportunity sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Be especially wary of unsolicited investment advice or pressure to act quickly. Take the time to verify information independently before making any investment decisions.
6. Understand the tax implications: Crypto ETF investments can have complex tax implications. Consult with a tax professional to understand how your investments might affect your tax situation.
7. Use reputable brokers: Only invest through well-known, regulated brokers. Check their credentials and read reviews from other users.
8. Monitor investments regularly: Keep an eye on your ETF's performance and any changes in its underlying assets or management strategy. However, avoid the temptation to make knee-jerk reactions to short-term market movements.
By understanding these unique challenges and taking proactive steps, you can navigate the crypto ETF landscape safely and confidently. Remember, in the world of investing, knowledge isn't just power - it's protection.
More: AI-powered stock ETFs were hyped as superior investments. Then reality hit.
Plus: How the presidential election is affecting the price of bitcoin and other crypto
-Jurica Dujmovic
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.